(section 31(2))
MODIFICATIONS TO THE ORDER WHEN APPLIED TO EXTERNAL CONFISCATION
ORDERS AND RELATED PROCEEDINGS
Application of Schedule and Introductory.
1.
This Schedule shall apply to external confiscation orders registered under section 32 and to any proceedings which have been or are to be instituted and which may result in such external confiscation ·orders being made in designated countries and, to the extent that it is at variance with the preceding sections of this
Order in relation to the administration and enforcement of external confiscation orders and proceedings which may result in external confiscation orders, the terms of this Schedule shall prevail.
Interpretation of Schedule.
2.
( 1)
In this Schedule -
1019
"charging order" means an order made under sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 7;
"conduct to which this Schedule applies" falls to be construed in accordance with sub-paragraph (a) of sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 3;
"dealing with property" means or (as the case may be) falls to be construed in accordance with sub-paragraph (9) of paragraph 6;
"defendant" falls to be construed in accordance with sub-paragraph (b) of sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 3;
"drug trafficking offence" has the same meaning as in subsection (1) of section 2 of the Emergency (Drug Trafficking) (Recovery of Proceeds)
Order, 1996 (S 12/96);
"gift caught by this Schedule" falls to be construed in accordance with sub-paragraph (4) of paragraph 3;
"realisable property" falls to be construed in accordance with sub-paragraph (2) of paragraph 3;
"restraint order" means an order made under sub-paragraph ( 1) of paragraph 6.
(2)
In this Schedule, proceedings are instituted in a designated country-
(a} when under the law of that country one of the steps specified in relation to that country in an order made under section 31 has been taken there in respect of alleged conduct by the defendant to which this Schedule applies; or
(bj when an application has been made to a court in a designated country for an external confiscation order, and where the application of this paragraph would result in there being more than one time for the institution of proceedings, they shall be taken to have been instituted at the earliest of those times.
(3)
In this Schedule, proceedings are concluded-
(a} when (disregarding any power of a court to grant leave to appeal out of time) there is no further possibility of an external confiscation order being made in the proceedings; or
(bj on the satisfaction of an external confiscation order made in the proceedings (whether by the recovery of all property liable to be recovered, or the payment of any amount due, or otherwise).
Definition of principal terms used in Schedule.
3.
(1)
In this Schedule -
(a} a reference to conduct to which this Schedule applies is a reference to conduct which -
{i)
constitutes an offence to which this Order applies or would constitute such an offence if it had occurred in Brunei
Darussalam, other than drug trafficking offences and offences which relate directly or indirectly to the regulation, imposition, calculation or collection of taxes subject to sub-paragraph (ii);
(ii)
constitutes an offence to which this Order applies or would constitute such an offence if it had occurred in Brunei
Darussalam and which involves -
(AJ dishonestly misappropriating or converting to one's own use any movable property by means of criminal breach of trust or cheating, or conspiring to do any of those acts, or accounting documents regulating or affecting benefits available in connection with the laws and regulations relating to income or other taxes; and 1020
(BJ wilfully making or conspiring to make any false written statement, to government tax authorities with respect to any tax matter arising from the unlawful proceeds of any criminal offence, or without reasonable excuse making an incorrect return to government tax authorities as required by law in respect of, or to pay the tax on, any such unlawful proceeds; and
(b/ a person against whom an external confiscation order has been made, or a person against whom proceedings which may result in an external confiscation order being made have been, or are to be, instituted in a Court of a designated country, is referred to as "the defendant".
(2)
In this Schedule, "realisable property" means, subject to sub-paragraph
(a} in relation to an external confiscation order in respect of specified property, the property which is specified in the order; and
(bJ in any· other case
(i)
any property held by the defendant; and
(ii)
any property held by a person to whom the defendant has directly or indirectly made a gift caught by this Order.
(3)
Property is not realisable property if an order under section 25 of the
Misuse of Drugs Act (Chapter 27) is in force in respect of the property.
(4)
A gift (including a gift made before the commencement of this Order) is caught by this Schedule if -
(a} it was made by the defendant at any time after the conduct to which the external confiscation order relates; and
(b/ the Court considers it appropriate in all the circumstances to take the gift into account.
Pecuniary Advantage - Equivalence.
4.
Where a person derives a pecuniary advantage as a result of or in connection with conduct to which this Schedule applies, he is to be treated for the purposes of this Schedule as if he had obtained as the result of or in connection with the conduct a sum of money equal to the value of the pecuniary advantage.
1021
Cases in which restraint orders and charging orders may be made.
5.
(1)
The powers conferred on the Court by sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 6
or sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 7 are exercisable where-
(a) proceedings have been instituted against the defendant in a designated country;
(b) the proceedings have not been concluded; and
(c) either an external confiscation order has been made in the proceedings or it appears to the Court that there are reasonable grounds for thinking that such an order may be made in them of at least the minimum amount.
(2)
Those powers are also exercisable where the Court is satisfied that proceedings will be instituted against the defendant in a designated country within seven days of the application for an order under sub-paragraph ( 1) of paragraph 6
or sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 7.
(3)
Where the Court has made an order under sub-paragraph \1) of paragraph 6 or sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 7 by virtue of sub-paragraph (2) of this paragraph -
(a) the Attorney General shall notify the Court immediately if proceedings have not been instituted within seven days of the application for the order; and
(b) the Court shall discharge the order if the proposed proceedings have not been instituted within seven days of the application for the order.
Restraint orders.
6.
( 1) The Court may by a restraint order prohibit any person from dealing with any realisable property, subject to such conditions and exceptions as may be specified in the order.
(2)
Without prejudice to the generality of sub-paragraph (1), a restraint order may make such provision as the Court thinks fit for the living expenses and legal expenses of the defendant.
(3)
A restraint order may apply-
(a) where an application under sub-paragraph (5) relates to an external confiscation order made in respect of specified property, to property which is specified in that order; and 1022
(b] in any other case-
(i)
to all realisable property held by a specified person, whether or not the property is described in the restraint order; and
(iil to realisable property held by a specified person, being property transferred to him after the making of the restraint order.
(4)
This paragraph shall not have effect in relation to any property for the time being subject to a charge under paragraph 7.
(5)
A restraint order-
{a) may be made only on an application by the Attorney General on behalf of the government of a designated country or, in a case where an external confiscation order has been registered under section 32, by a receiver appointed under paragraph 9;
{b)
may b~ made on an ex parte application to a judge in chambers; and
{c) notwithstanding anything in the Rules of the Supreme Court
(S 5/90), may provide for service on, or the provision of notice to, persons affected by the order in such manner as the Court may direct.
(6)
A restraint order-
{a) may be discharged or varied in relation to any property; and
{b)
shall be discharged when the proceedings in relation to which the order was made have been concluded.
(7)
An application for the discharge or variation of a restraint order may be made by any person affected by it.
(8)
Where the Court has made a restraint order, it may at any time appoint a receiver
{a] to take possession of any realisable property; and
{b] in accordance with the Court's directions, to manage or otherwise deal with any property in respect of which he is appointed, subject to such conditions and exceptions as may be specified by the Court; and may require any person having possession of property in respect of which a receiver is. appointed under this section to give possession of it to the receiver.
1023
19)
For the purpose of this paragraph, dealing with any property held by any person includes !without prejudice to the generality of the expression)
{a) where a debt is owed to that person, making a payment to any person in reduction of the amount of the debt; and
{b) removing the property from Brunei Darussalam.
110) Where the Court has made a restraint order, a police officer may, for the purpose of preventing any realisable property being removed from Brunei
Darussalam, seize the property.
Ill} Property seized under sub-paragraph 110} shall be dealt with in accordance with the Court's directions.
1 12) In the case of a restraint order made in respect of land
{a) the restraint order shall inhibit for a specified period of time or until the occurrence of a specified event, or generally until further order, the registration of any dealing with any land, lease or charge;
{b) a copy of the restraint order under the seal of the Court, with the particulars of the land, lease or charge thereby affected shall be sent to the officer in charge of the Land Office who shall register it in the
Register kept by him under section 7 of the Land Code !Chapter 40)
in respect of that land and no restraint order shall bind or affect the land, lease or charge until it has been registere~;
lc)
so long as the restraint order remains registered no instrument which is inconsistent with it shall be registered.
Charging orders.
7.
11}
The Court may make a charging order on realisable property for securing the payment to the Government -
(a} where a fixed amount is payable under an external confiscation order, of an amount not exceeding the amount so payable; and
{b) in any other case, of an amount equal to the value from time to time of the property charged.
(2)
For the purposes of this Schedule, a charging order is an order which imposes on any such realisable property as may be specified in the order a charge for securing the payment of money to the Government.
1024
(3}
A charging order -
{a} may be made only on an application by the Attorney General on behalf of the government of a designated country or, in a case where an external confiscation order has been registered under section 32, by a receiver appointed under paragraph 9;
{b) may be made on an ex parte application to a judge in chambers;
fc} notwithstanding anything in the Rules of the Supreme Court
(S 5/90), may provide for service on, or the provision of notice to, persons affected by the order in such manner as the Court may direct.
(4)
Subject to sub-paragraph (6), a charge may be imposed by a charging order only on -
1025
{a} any interest in realisable property, being an interest held beneficially by the defendant or by a person to whom the defendant has dire~tly or indirectly made a gift caught by this Order -
(i)
in any asset of a kind mentioned in sub-paragraph (5);
(ii)
under any trust; or
{b) any interest in realisable property held by a person as trustee of a trust if the interest is in such an asset or is an interest under another trust, and a charge may by virtue of sub-paragraph {a} be imposed by a charging order on the whole beneficial interest under the first-mentioned trust.
(5)
The assets referred to in sub-paragraph (4) are-
{a} land in Brunei Darussalam; or
{b) securities of any of the following kinds
(i)
any description of security issued by or on behalf of the
Government;
(ii)
stock or shares in any limited company or other body registered under the Companies Act (Chapter 39);
[iii)
stock or shares in any international business company registered under the International Business Companies Order,
2000;
(iv)
equity interests in any mutual funds; or
(vl funds in court.
(6)
In any case where a charge is imposed by a charging order on any interest in an asset of a kind mentioned in sub-paragraph (b) of sub-paragraph ~5), the Court may provide for the charge to extend to any interest or dividend payable in respect of such asset.
(7)
The Court may make an order discharging or varying the charging order if the proceedings against the defendant in the designated country have been concluded or the amount, payment of which is secured by the charge, has been paid into Court.
(8)
An application for the discharge or variation of a charging order may be made by any person affected by it.
(9)
A charge imposed by a charging order made in relation to any interest in land shall be registered as a charge in the Register kept under the Land Code
(Chapter 40) by the officer in charge of the Land Office.
(10)
Subject to any provision made under paragraph 9 or by Rules of Court, a charge imposed by a charging order shall have the like effect and shall be enforceable in the same courts and in the same manner as an equitable charge created by the person holding the beneficial interest or, as the case may be, the trustees by writing under their hand.
Applications for restraint and charging orders.
8. An application under sub-paragraph (5) of paragraph 6 or sub-paragraph (3) of paragraph 7 shall be accompanied by an affidavit by the appropriate authority of the designated country deposing to -
(a) where proceedings have been instituted, the conduct in which the defendant is alleged to have engaged (exhibiting a copy of the indictment, information or charge), and the grounds for believing that the defendant engaged in that conduct;
(b) where proceedings will be instituted within seven days of the application, the conduct in which the defendant will be alleged to have engaged, and the grounds for believing that the defendant engaged in that conduct;
(c) where an external confiscation order has been made, the amount payable under the confiscation order;
(d) where an external confiscation order has not been made 1026
(i)
the grounds for the belief that the defendant derived a benefit of a stated amount as a result of the conduct;
(ii)
the grounds for the belief that the amount that might be realised is at least the stated amount;
(iii)
where proceedings have been instituted, the grounds for believing that an external confiscation order may be made and the amount likely to be payable under such a confiscation order; or jiv) where proceedings are to be instituted within seven days of the application, the grounds for believing that an external confiscation order is likely to be made and the amount likely to be payable under such a confiscation order;
{e)
a description of the property in respect of which the order is sought;
{(}
the grounds for the belief that the property is realisable property;
{g} the name and address of the person who is believed to be in the possession of the property; and
{h} the names and addresses of any parties who may have any interest in that property, and the nature of their interest.
Realisation of property.
9.
(1)
Where an external confiscation order has been registered in the Court under section 32, the Court may, on an application of the Attorney General-
1027
{a} in respect of any sum of money payable under the external confiscation order, make a garnishee order as if the sum were due to the Government in pursuance of a judgment or order of the Court, but any such order shall direct that the sum payable be paid to the
Court;
(b} appoint a receiver in respect of the realisable property;
(c) empower a receiver appointed under sub-paragraph (8) of paragraph 6, or in pursuance of a charging order
!i)
to enforce any charge imposed under paragraph 10 on realisable property or on interest or dividends payable in respect of such property; and
(ii)
in relation to any realisable property, other than property for the time being subject to a charge under paragraph 10, to take possession of the property subject to such conditions and exceptions as may be specifted by the Court;
{d)
order any person having possession of the property to give possession of it to any such receiver;
{e)
empower any such receiver to realise any realisable property in such manner as it may direct; and
{f) order any person holding an interest in any realisable property to make such payment to the receiver in respect of any beneftcial interest held by the defendant or, as the case may be, the recipient of a gift caught by this Schedule as it may direct and, on the payment being made, may by order transfer, grant or extinguish any interest in the property.
(2)
Sub-paragraphs {d), {e) and {f) do not apply to property for the time being subject to a charge under paragraph 7.
Application of proceeds of realisation and other sums.
10.
(1)
Subject to sub-paragraph (2), such of-
{a) the proceeds of the enforcement of any charge imposed under paragraph 7;
{b) the proceeds of the realisation, other than by the enforcement of such a charge, of any property under paragraphs 6 or 9; or
{c) any other sums, being property held by the defendant, as may be in the hands of a receiver appointed under this Order or in pursuance of a charging order shall, after such payments (if any) as the Court may direct have been made out of those sums, be paid to the Court and applied for the purposes specifted in sub-paragraphs (3) and (4) and in the order so specifted.
(2)
Where a fixed amount is payable under the external conftscation order and, after that amount has been fully paid, any such sums remain in the hands of a receiver, the receiver shall distribute them
{a) among such of those persons who held property which has been realised under this Schedule; and
{b} in such proportions,
1028
as the Court may direct after giving a reasonable opportunity for such persons to make representations to the Court.
(3}
If the money was paid to the Court by a receiver appointed under paragraphs 6 or 9, or in pursuance of a charging order, the receiver's remuneration and expenses shall next be paid.
(4)
After any payment required by sub-paragraph (3) has been made, any amount paid under sub-paragraph (2) of paragraph 14 shall be reimbursed.
(5)
Any sums remaining after all the payments required to be made under the foregoing provisions of this section have been made shall be paid to the
Government.
Exercise of powers of Court or receiver.
11.
(1)
This paragraph applies to the powers conferred on the Court by paragraphs 6, 7, 9 and 10, or on a receiver appointed under this Schedule or in pursuance of a charging order.
(2)
Subject to the following provisions of this section, those powers shall be exercised with a view to recovering property which is liable to be recovered under an external confiscation order registered in the Court under section 32 or, as the case may be, with a view to making available for recovery property which may become liable to be recovered under any external confiscation order which may be made in the defendant's case.
(3)
In the case of realisable property held by a person to whom the defendant has directly or indirectly made a gift caught by this Schedule, the powers shall be exercised with a view to realising no more than the value for the time being of the gift.
(4)
The powers shall be exercised with a view to allowing any person other than the defendant or the recipient of any such gift to retain or recover the value of any property held by him.
!5)
An order may be made or other action taken in respect of a debt held by the Government.
(6)
Subject to sub-paragraph (2) of paragraph 3, in exercising those powers, no account shall be taken of any obligations of the defendant or of the recipient of any such gift which conflict with the obligation to satisfy the external confiscation order.
1029
Bankruptcy of defendant, etc.
12.
(1)
Where an order of adjudication for bankruptcy has been made against a person who holds realisable property -
(a}
any property subject for the time being to a restraint order made before the order for bankruptcy; and
(b) any proceeds of property realised under sub-paragraph (8) of paragraph 6 or sub-paragraphs (e) or ({} of sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 9 for the time being in the hands of a receiver appointed under paragraphs 6 or 9, is excluded from the property of the bankrupt for the purposes of the Bankruptcy
Act !Chapter 67).
(2)
Where any order of adjudication for bankruptcy has been made against any person, the powers conferred on the Court by paragraphs 6, 7, 9 and 10 or on a receiver appointed by such order shall not be exercised in relation to -
(a} property for the time being comprised in the bankrupt's estate for the purposes of the Bankruptcy Act (Chapter 67);
(b) property which is to be applied for the benefit of creditors of the bankrupt under any provision of or any condition imposed under subsection (3) of section 30 of that Act.
(3)
Nothing in the Bankruptcy Act (Chapter 67) shall be taken as restricting, or enabling the restriction of the exercise of the powers conferred on the Court by paragraphs 6, 7, 9 and 10 or on a receiver.
(4)
Sub-paragraph (2) does not affect the enforcement of a charging order
(a} made before the order of adjudication for bankruptcy was made; or
(b) on property which was subject to a restraint order when the order for bankruptcy was made.
(5)
Where in the case of a debtor
(a} the Official Receiver appointed by section 12 of the Bankruptcy Act
(Chapter 67) has been ordered to become the receiver or manager of the property, estate or business of the debtor; and
(b) any property of the debtor is subject to a restraint order, the powers conferred on the Official Receiver under that Act do not apply to property for the time being subject to the restraint order.
1030
l6) Where any order for bankruptcy has been made against a person who has directly or indirectly made a gift caught by this Schedule, sections 31 and 47 of the Bankruptcy Act (Chapter 67) shall not apply when property of the person to whom the gift was made is subject to a restraint order or charging order.
Winding up of company holding realisable property.
13.
( 1)
Where realisable property is held by a company and an order for the winding up of the company has been made or a resolution has been passed by the company for the voluntary winding up, the functions of the liquidator (or any provisional liquidator) shall not be exercisable in relation to -
(a) any property for the time being subject to a restraint order made before the relevant time; and
(b)
any proceeds of property realised under sub-paragraph (8) of paragraph 6 or sub-paragraphs (e) or (f) of sub-paragraph Ill of paragraph 9 for the time being in the hands of a receiver appointed under paragraphs 6 or 9.
[2}
Where such an order has been made or such a resolution has been passed, the powers conferred on the Court by paragraphs 6, 7 and 9 or on a receiver appointed by the order shall not be exercised in relation to any realisable property held by the company in relation to which the functions of the liquidator are exercisable so as to -
(a)
inhibit him from exerc1smg those functions for the purpose of distributing any property held by the company to the company's creditors; or
(b)
prevent the payment out of any property of any expenses (including the remuneration of the liquidator or any provisional liquidator)
properly incurred in the winding up in respect of the property.
(3)
Sub-paragraph (2) does not affect the enforcement of a charging order made before the relevant time or on property which was subject to a restraint order at the relevant time.
1031
(4)
In this paragraph, "relevant time" means-
(a) where no order for the winding up of the company has been made, the time of the passing of the resolution for voluntary winding up;
(b) where such an order has been made and, before the presentation of the petition for the winding up of the company by the Court, such a resolution had been passed by the company, the time of the passing of the resolution; and
(c)
in any other case where such an order has been made,· the time of the making of the order.
Receivers: supplementary provisions.
14. Ill Where a receiver appointed under this Schedule or in pursuance of a charging order takes any action -
(a) in relation to any property which is not realisable property, being action which he would be entitled to take if it were such property;
and
(b) believing, and having reasonable grounds for believing, that he is entitled to take that action in relation to that property, he shall not be liable to any person in respect of any loss or damage resulting from his action except in so far as the loss or damage was caused by his negligence.
[2)
Any amount due in respect of the remuneration and expenses of a receiver so appointed shall, if no sum is available to be applied in payment of it under sub-paragraph (3) of paragraph 10, be paid by the person on whose application the receiver was appointed.
Application of procedure for enforcing fines.
15.
(1)
Where the Court has ordered the defendant to pay any amount under this Schedule, sections 253, 254, 255 and 256 of the Criminal Procedure Code
(Chapter 7) shall have effect as if that amount were a fine imposed on him by the
Court.
(a) the Court has directed that in default of payment of an amount ordered to be paid under this Schedule in respect of an offence the defendant shall serve a term of imprisonment; and
(b) at the time the direction was made, the defendant was liable to serve a term of imprisonment in respect of the offence, the term of imprisonment to be served in default of payment of the amount shall not begin to run until after the term of imprisonment mentioned in sub-paragraph
1032
{3)
For the purpose of sub-paragraph (b} of sub-paragraph (2) -
{a} consecutive terms of imprisonment and terms of imprisonment which are wholly or partly concurrent shall be treated as a single term; and
(bJ there shall be disregarded any sentence suspended under any law relating to the suspension of sentences if that sentence had not taken effect at the time the defendant defaulted as specified in the direction.
Made this 21st. day of Safar, 1421 Hijriah corresponding to the 25th. day of
May, 2000 at Our Istana Nurul Iman, Bandar Seri Begawan, Brunei Darussalam.
1033
HIS MAJESTY
THE SULTAN AND YANG DI-PERTUAN
BRUNEI DARUSSALAM